26.08.24
The problem with a book emulating Georgette Heyer is that it's not Georgette Heyer. Even if you try not to compare, you can't help thinking that Heyer wouldn't explain every thought and action, wouldn't focus so much on exposition, that her heroine wouldn't need rescuing quite so much, that her characters would sparkle and the grasp of social etiquette would be stronger. (Also it would be properly edited and proofread - this had several iffy editorial moments.) I mean, this is fun and has a strong historical basis that didn't shy away from the gritty lives of the poor but it needed a stronger basis and more differentiation from Heyer to really break free. (Note that I've also given a couple of Heyer's books 51/52%.)
No comments:
Post a Comment