68%
22.05.08
On the one hand, Chabon writes with a lyricism you can roll in and savour and think 'this is where the others go wrong'. On the other, his cleverness can get the better of him and it's hard to know what's going on. But for his ambition, his imagination, his surreal world view, he is certainly up there with the best modern novelists. [Later note: this was a reading group choice in early 2009 and was unanimously unpopular for being too pretentious. While that is certainly a flaw, the actual plot and ideas raised should have stoked a good discussion.]
Showing posts with label Chabon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chabon. Show all posts
Summerland - Michael Chabon
63%
17.08.03
Chabon does his version of 'Northern Lights' for Americans, and doesn't quite come up to scratch. Obsessively researched, as usual, but generally too surreal to hang together as well as his previous novels. Drawing philosophical lessons from baseball doesn't impress British readers. But as an attempt at a new American epic, it's certainly original.
17.08.03
Chabon does his version of 'Northern Lights' for Americans, and doesn't quite come up to scratch. Obsessively researched, as usual, but generally too surreal to hang together as well as his previous novels. Drawing philosophical lessons from baseball doesn't impress British readers. But as an attempt at a new American epic, it's certainly original.
Wonder Boys - Michael Chabon
71%
09.08.02
More farcical, less historically ambitious than 'Kavalier and Clay', but just as elegant and touching, with the same sudden shafts of illumination that catch you unawares. I'm not sure many writers could succeed in producing such a funny novel about a man man bent on self-destruction.
09.08.02
More farcical, less historically ambitious than 'Kavalier and Clay', but just as elegant and touching, with the same sudden shafts of illumination that catch you unawares. I'm not sure many writers could succeed in producing such a funny novel about a man man bent on self-destruction.
The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Clay - Michael Chabon
78%
18.06.02
It took me a long time to read this book - and not just because it's nearly 700 pages long. For the first two-thirds, it's clear why this won the Pulitzer Prize last year - elegant poetic prose, enjoyable for its own sake, even without the complex, involving narrative that carries you along with its exuberance. But suddenly, 'White Teeth'-like, it loses its momentum and tails off into something still impressive, but less remarkable. Overall, however, the kind of novel I know I could never write.
18.06.02
It took me a long time to read this book - and not just because it's nearly 700 pages long. For the first two-thirds, it's clear why this won the Pulitzer Prize last year - elegant poetic prose, enjoyable for its own sake, even without the complex, involving narrative that carries you along with its exuberance. But suddenly, 'White Teeth'-like, it loses its momentum and tails off into something still impressive, but less remarkable. Overall, however, the kind of novel I know I could never write.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



